{"primaryDescription":"<h2><strong>What lessons has HMRC learned from Child Benefits blunder? PAC investigates</strong></h2>\r\n<p>The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) will hold an evidence session on HMRC's use of Home Office data to investigate potential fraud and error in Child Benefit claims on Thursday 29 October at 10.00am.</p>","secondaryDescription":"<p>HMRC estimates that fraud and error in Child Benefit amounted to &pound;270m in 2024-25. In 2025, HMRC implemented a new approach using Home Office data to investigate potential fraud and error in Child Benefit claims. This rollout resulted in 23,794 claimants having payments suspended, with later investigations confirming that almost two thirds of these claimants were eligible to receive Child Benefits.</p>\r\n<p>The PAC will investigate what safeguards HMRC has introduced to protect eligible claimants when planning and monitoring future compliance interventions. Questions may also consider whether changes provide sufficient oversight and accountability and how HMRC will factor customer experience into future decisions.</p>\r\n<p>Witnesses could be asked about plans for tackling fraud and error in Child Benefit expenditure, and how the lessons learned can be applied across Government, with a focus on continuing to foster innovation.&nbsp;</p>","parliamentTvUrl":"https://parliamentlive.tv/event/index/958d257c-5d1b-4f21-8495-6ccbcb028d9d","id":28486,"name":null,"startDate":"2026-10-29T09:30:00","endDate":"2026-10-29T12:30:00","cancelledDate":null,"locationId":10,"location":"The Grimond Room, Portcullis House","eventType":{"id":6,"name":"Formal meeting (oral evidence session)","isVisit":false,"description":"Formal meetings may be held in private (for example to consider a draft report) or in public (for example to hear oral evidence), and require a minimum number of members to be present."},"eventSource":"CIS","committees":[{"contact":{"email":"pubaccom@parliament.uk","phone":null,"address":"Public Accounts Committee, House of Commons, London, SW1A 0AA","contactDisclaimer":"We receive a significant number of emails each day. All requests and invitations are considered but we do not respond directly to everyone.\r\nPlease be aware, the committee does not look at individual cases or specific complaints."},"id":127,"name":"Public Accounts Committee","parentCommittee":null,"subCommittees":[],"house":"Commons","leadHouse":null,"category":{"id":1,"name":"Select"},"committeeTypes":[{"id":22,"name":"(HC) Public Standing Orders - Cross-cutting","committeeCategory":{"id":1,"name":"Select"}}],"showOnWebsite":true,"websiteLegacyUrl":"https://old.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/commons-select/public-accounts-committee/","websiteLegacyRedirectEnabled":false,"startDate":"1978-11-01T00:00:00","endDate":null,"dateCommonsAppointed":"2024-10-21T00:00:00","dateLordsAppointed":null,"scrutinisingDepartments":[],"isLeadCommittee":true,"nameHistory":[{"id":125,"committeeId":127,"name":"Public Accounts Committee","startDate":"1978-11-01T00:00:00","endDate":null}]}],"committeeBusinesses":[{"id":9766,"title":"HMRC’s anti-fraud intervention on child benefit","type":{"id":1,"name":"Inquiry","isInquiry":true,"description":"Inquiries allow committees to consider oral and written evidence on a particular topic. They usually result in the publication of a report."},"openDate":"2026-04-24T00:00:00","closeDate":null,"latestReport":null,"openSubmissionPeriods":[],"closedSubmissionPeriods":[],"nextOralEvidenceSession":null,"contact":{"email":"pubaccom@parliament.uk","phone":null,"address":null,"contactDisclaimer":null}}],"childEvents":[],"nextActivity":null,"activities":[{"committeeBusinesses":[{"id":9766,"title":"HMRC’s anti-fraud intervention on child benefit","type":{"id":1,"name":"Inquiry","isInquiry":true,"description":"Inquiries allow committees to consider oral and written evidence on a particular topic. They usually result in the publication of a report."},"openDate":"2026-04-24T00:00:00","closeDate":null,"latestReport":null,"openSubmissionPeriods":[],"closedSubmissionPeriods":[],"nextOralEvidenceSession":null,"contact":{"email":"pubaccom@parliament.uk","phone":null,"address":null,"contactDisclaimer":null}}],"oralEvidences":[],"id":39121,"name":null,"startDate":"2026-10-29T09:30:00","endDate":"2026-10-29T10:00:00","eventId":28486,"isPrivate":true,"activityType":"Private discussion","attendees":[]},{"committeeBusinesses":[{"id":9766,"title":"HMRC’s anti-fraud intervention on child benefit","type":{"id":1,"name":"Inquiry","isInquiry":true,"description":"Inquiries allow committees to consider oral and written evidence on a particular topic. They usually result in the publication of a report."},"openDate":"2026-04-24T00:00:00","closeDate":null,"latestReport":null,"openSubmissionPeriods":[],"closedSubmissionPeriods":[],"nextOralEvidenceSession":null,"contact":{"email":"pubaccom@parliament.uk","phone":null,"address":null,"contactDisclaimer":null}}],"oralEvidences":[],"id":39122,"name":null,"startDate":"2026-10-29T10:00:00","endDate":"2026-10-29T12:00:00","eventId":28486,"isPrivate":false,"activityType":"Oral evidence","attendees":[{"displayOrder":1,"organisations":[{"name":"HMRC","role":"Permanent Secretary and Chief Executive","idmsId":null,"cisId":395}],"submitterType":0,"additionalContext":null,"id":37219,"personId":123894,"name":"John-Paul Marks CB","photoUrl":null,"memberInfo":null},{"displayOrder":2,"organisations":[{"name":"HMRC","role":"Director of Individuals Policy","idmsId":null,"cisId":395}],"submitterType":0,"additionalContext":null,"id":37220,"personId":1364,"name":"Cerys McDonald","photoUrl":null,"memberInfo":null},{"displayOrder":3,"organisations":[{"name":"HMRC","role":"Director General Customer Services","idmsId":null,"cisId":395}],"submitterType":0,"additionalContext":null,"id":37221,"personId":80475,"name":"Myrtle Lloyd","photoUrl":null,"memberInfo":null},{"displayOrder":5,"organisations":[{"name":"Public Sector Fraud Authority","role":"Deputy Director Data/AI and Chair of DEA Board","idmsId":null,"cisId":97939}],"submitterType":0,"additionalContext":null,"id":37222,"personId":126099,"name":"Rob Malcomson","photoUrl":null,"memberInfo":null},{"displayOrder":4,"organisations":[{"name":"HMRC","role":"Director General Strategy & Policy","idmsId":null,"cisId":395}],"submitterType":0,"additionalContext":null,"id":37271,"personId":25755,"name":"Jonathan Athow","photoUrl":null,"memberInfo":null}]}]}