{"primaryDescription":"<h2>What are the reasons for the dual role of the Lord Advocate? &nbsp;</h2>\r\n<p>The Scottish Affairs Committee holds the first evidence session of its inquiry into the <a href=\"https://committees.parliament.uk/event/28319/formal-meeting-oral-evidence-session/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"><u>dual role of the Lord Advocate.</u></a>&nbsp;&nbsp;</p>\r\n<p>This inquiry aims to explore the case for and against the \"dual role\" of the Lord Advocate, in which they serve concurrently as a senior Scottish Government legal advisor and the ministerial head of Scotland's public prosecutions service.</p>","secondaryDescription":"<p>In the first panel, the cross-party committee will hear from legal academics Dr Conor McCormick and Dr Andrew Tickell on the reasons behind the dual role and the debate surrounding its value. Questions may explore the safeguards to protect public prosecutions from political interference, the political sensitivities of the role and potential conflicts of interest, as well as alternatives to the dual role.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p>\r\n<p>MPs will then hear from the Law Society of Scotland, the regulatory body for Scottish solicitors, and Malcolm McMillan, author of the McMillan Review into the role and functions of devolved law officers. MPs could examine the McMillan Review, the Law Society of Scotland's calls for reform of the role and the effectiveness of existing safeguards of prosecutorial independence.</p>","parliamentTvUrl":"https://parliamentlive.tv/event/index/56d24d8f-b422-42a5-9bc6-cb5b431988b8","id":28319,"name":"The dual role of the Lord Advocate – Session 1","startDate":"2026-11-04T09:00:00","endDate":"2026-11-04T11:30:00","cancelledDate":null,"locationId":8,"location":"Room 15, Palace of Westminster","eventType":{"id":6,"name":"Formal meeting (oral evidence session)","isVisit":false,"description":"Formal meetings may be held in private (for example to consider a draft report) or in public (for example to hear oral evidence), and require a minimum number of members to be present."},"eventSource":"CIS","committees":[{"contact":{"email":"scotaffcom@parliament.uk","phone":null,"address":"Scottish Affairs Committee, House of Commons, London, SW1A 0AA","contactDisclaimer":"We receive a significant number of emails each day. All requests and invitations are considered but we do not respond directly to everyone.\r\nPlease be aware, the committee does not look at individual cases or specific complaints."},"id":136,"name":"Scottish Affairs Committee","parentCommittee":null,"subCommittees":[],"house":"Commons","leadHouse":null,"category":{"id":1,"name":"Select"},"committeeTypes":[{"id":1,"name":"(HC) Public Standing Orders - Departmental","committeeCategory":{"id":1,"name":"Select"}}],"showOnWebsite":true,"websiteLegacyUrl":"https://old.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/commons-select/scottish-affairs-committee/","websiteLegacyRedirectEnabled":false,"startDate":"1979-05-03T00:00:00","endDate":null,"dateCommonsAppointed":"2024-10-21T00:00:00","dateLordsAppointed":null,"scrutinisingDepartments":[],"isLeadCommittee":true,"nameHistory":[{"id":134,"committeeId":136,"name":"Scottish Affairs Committee","startDate":"1979-05-03T00:00:00","endDate":null}]}],"committeeBusinesses":[{"id":9993,"title":"The dual role of the Lord Advocate","type":{"id":1,"name":"Inquiry","isInquiry":true,"description":"Inquiries allow committees to consider oral and written evidence on a particular topic. They usually result in the publication of a report."},"openDate":"2026-09-09T00:00:00","closeDate":null,"latestReport":null,"openSubmissionPeriods":[],"closedSubmissionPeriods":[],"nextOralEvidenceSession":null,"contact":{"email":"scotaffcom@parliament.uk","phone":null,"address":null,"contactDisclaimer":null}}],"childEvents":[],"nextActivity":null,"activities":[{"committeeBusinesses":[],"oralEvidences":[],"id":38907,"name":null,"startDate":"2026-11-04T09:00:00","endDate":"2026-11-04T09:30:00","eventId":28319,"isPrivate":true,"activityType":"Private discussion","attendees":[]},{"committeeBusinesses":[{"id":9993,"title":"The dual role of the Lord Advocate","type":{"id":1,"name":"Inquiry","isInquiry":true,"description":"Inquiries allow committees to consider oral and written evidence on a particular topic. They usually result in the publication of a report."},"openDate":"2026-09-09T00:00:00","closeDate":null,"latestReport":null,"openSubmissionPeriods":[],"closedSubmissionPeriods":[],"nextOralEvidenceSession":null,"contact":{"email":"scotaffcom@parliament.uk","phone":null,"address":null,"contactDisclaimer":null}}],"oralEvidences":[],"id":38908,"name":null,"startDate":"2026-11-04T09:30:00","endDate":"2026-11-04T10:30:00","eventId":28319,"isPrivate":false,"activityType":"Oral evidence","attendees":[{"displayOrder":1,"organisations":[{"name":"Glasgow Caledonian University","role":"Head of Department, Department of Economics and Law","idmsId":"https://id.parliament.uk/1pR5wmwJ","cisId":39963}],"submitterType":0,"additionalContext":null,"id":37465,"personId":127088,"name":"Dr Andrew Tickell","photoUrl":null,"memberInfo":null},{"displayOrder":2,"organisations":[{"name":"Queen's University Belfast","role":"Reader in Law","idmsId":"https://id.parliament.uk/qtByEq2A","cisId":68234}],"submitterType":0,"additionalContext":null,"id":37466,"personId":53131,"name":"Dr Conor McCormick","photoUrl":null,"memberInfo":null}]},{"committeeBusinesses":[{"id":9993,"title":"The dual role of the Lord Advocate","type":{"id":1,"name":"Inquiry","isInquiry":true,"description":"Inquiries allow committees to consider oral and written evidence on a particular topic. They usually result in the publication of a report."},"openDate":"2026-09-09T00:00:00","closeDate":null,"latestReport":null,"openSubmissionPeriods":[],"closedSubmissionPeriods":[],"nextOralEvidenceSession":null,"contact":{"email":"scotaffcom@parliament.uk","phone":null,"address":null,"contactDisclaimer":null}}],"oralEvidences":[],"id":39367,"name":null,"startDate":"2026-11-04T10:30:00","endDate":"2026-11-04T11:30:00","eventId":28319,"isPrivate":false,"activityType":"Oral evidence","attendees":[{"displayOrder":1,"organisations":[{"name":"Law Society of Scotland","role":"Director of Law Reform","idmsId":"https://id.parliament.uk/j0LhriuB","cisId":50653}],"submitterType":0,"additionalContext":null,"id":37470,"personId":2166,"name":"Michael Clancy","photoUrl":null,"memberInfo":null},{"displayOrder":2,"organisations":[{"name":"Scottish Law Commission","role":"Former Chief Executive","idmsId":"https://id.parliament.uk/3BvalDFR","cisId":73105}],"submitterType":0,"additionalContext":null,"id":37471,"personId":127091,"name":"Malcolm McMillan","photoUrl":null,"memberInfo":null}]}]}